Small Business Valuation:
A Buyer's Perspective
In deciding how much to pay for a
business, buyers consider a number of factors that are
considered more or less
important depending upon the needs of the specific
buyer. While matching a business with the right buyer
requires business savvy and
skillful negotiation, there are certain concerns voiced
by buyers that we at Business
Appraisal Consultants continue to
hear:
WILL THE SELLER HELP WITH
FINANCING? Time after time, we find the terms to be
more important than the stated price. The overriding
importance of terms can be traced to at least two
factors:
Typically, the potential buyer has
neither the capital nor the borrowing power to pay the
entire price in cash. If he did, he would probably be
looking for a larger business! The willingness of the
seller to "carry the paper" comforts the buyer by
helping to assure him of the seller's confidence in the
future of the business. In addition, a buyer may be less
anxious about parting with their cash when the seller
remains motivated to express their confidence in the
ability of the new owners among both current and
potential customers. DOES THE BUSINESS THROW-OFF ENOUGH
CASH TO ALLOW THE BUYER A REASONABLE WAGE? While buyers
often recognize that income must be sacrificed until any
note is fully repaid, most require that the business
allow a salary that provides them with a living wage. As
a general rule, the buyer with more money wants both a
larger business and a higher wage: but the buyer of even
the smallest business typically needs at least some
money to live.
IS CASH FLOW ADEQUATE TO PROVIDE
NEEDED REPLACEMENT OF EQUIPMENT? An unfortunate fact
of life is that aging equipment must be maintained,
repaired and eventually replaced. While often viewed as
part of "discretionary income," the element of cash flow
known as depreciation must generally be reinvested to
keep from cannibalizing business assets. In most cases,
depreciation generated funds must be used to replace at
least some equipment before a business is fully paid
for. When the capital stock must be immediately replaced
or expanded, a buyer may reduce the offering price to
offset the needed capital expenditures.
HOW LONG WILL IT TAKE TO FULLY PAY
FOR THE BUSINESS? For small businesses, buyers want
to pay for the business within a reasonable period,
typically three to seven years. Real estate, commonly
viewed as an item separate from the business, can
sometimes be financed through a long term lease. In
other cases, the real estate may be sold to another
party or made available to the buyer in the form of a
lease.
HOW LONG WILL IT TAKE THE BUYER TO
LEARN THE BUSINESS? As a general rule, one can
expect a broader market for a business that is easier to
learn and more easily transferred. One should not be
surprised to find that buyers often expect sellers to
remain with the business until the "tricks of the trade"
have been passed on.
WHAT ARE THE FIRM'S FUTURE
PROSPECTS? While future prospects are often "driven"
by proven earnings, buyers are apt to pay more for a
growing business in a growing industry that has been
able to carve its own market niche. When the future is
clouded and operating problems have emerged, it is more
difficult to convince buyers to pay for "blue sky."
However, a firm with a well developed business plan may
stand out in the minds of a prospective buyer and be
given more consideration than the great majority of
firms that do not have such plan.
Although some buyers have been known
in some cases to be swayed by the prospects for
turnaround, most buyers looking for a turnaround
candidate are only willing to pay a fraction of hard
asset value.
CAN ANY GOODWILL REALLY BE
TRANSFERRED? While there is often intangible value
to a "turn key" operation with a trained and assembled
workforce, payment for goodwill usually requires that
the buyer be convinced that a high level of profits will
continue after the business is sold. Often, the value
placed by a buyer on such goodwill is tempered by the
knowledge that, for the goodwill to survive, it must
continually be "fed" (with the buyer's money).
|